Check out HJH–which actually means His Joseon Highness–on Jim Holt on Jonathan Nossiter on, to a large extent, the disaster wrought by Robert Parker and his pretentious and pox-palated epigones:

Here is what [Nossiter] hates: rich, fat, sweet, super-concentrated, overripe, jam-dense, high-alcohol, oaky, inky-colored, vanilla-y wines with no sense of place or identity.

And Californian customs have spread. Just as I happen to know the best midday meal you’ll get in Barcelona costs 10€ and is in a bar no one has ever heard of behind a police station about four miles from the nearest tourist, I think it’s true that if you chart quality against price for the 2-15€/bottle range of Spanish wines (I’m talking supermarket prices) you get something approaching a normal distribution, with quality increasing up to about 8€/bottle and then dropping quite sharply as you reach the segment occupied by new, fancy-labelled, undrinkable Somotano and Priorat and whatever product (this stuff may be sippable-and-spitoutable for all I know, but that’s not what wine is about).

My favourite wine clocks in at 10% (so you can have a decent drink at lunch without getting shrewish or even shirrhoshish) and costs 0.75 a litre from the supplier, who brings it down the Ebro in something resembling a Soviet muckspreader and leaves it in any large receptacle you have to hand.

El Primo c/o the commental asylum tells me that Don Simón is good stuff, but you don’t necessarily want to trust anything he says either.

Tags: Barcelona, California, fashion, Priorat, Rioja, Robert Parker, Somontano, Spain, value for money, walking, walking tours, wine
Categories: Acute diseases, Cultivation of the fields, Drink, Les bourgeois

RSS: post comments, blog comments, blog posts

You can leave a response. Pinging is currently closed due to spam generated by Jared Croslow's Deep Link Engine. (Temporary fix: turn off trackbacks with MySQL: UPDATE wp_posts SET ping_status="closed"; )

1. Tom
   October 26th 2009 07:44

   The vanilla-y merlot and the smoked tempranillo (but the merlot especially, oh and shiraz too) – make me sick. Sometimes they just make the skin on my lips peel off (as happened after a couple of glasses of Mallorcan Murder a few weeks back). But don’t you dare go after grenache fuelled Priorats of my heart. Granted, every week there’s a new one and I’ve tried most of them and stick to what I know. Scala Dei (€9-10) and Les Terrasses (€20) are both very drinkable with a meal.

   But you’re right: you can quite easily pay a lot less than that for perfectly acceptable wine.

   By the way, tried a ‘gold medal’ Toro on Saturday night. Now that was a wine made for spitting out.

2. Tweets that mention kalebeul » Why most American (and a considerable proportion of Spanish wine) is crap — Topsy.com
   October 26th 2009 11:09

   [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Stephenie Noah, Steve Remillong. Steve Remillong said: kalebeul » Why most American (and a considerable proportion of … http://bit.ly/867me [...]

3. Horace Jeffery Hodges
   October 26th 2009 23:33

   Thanks, Trevor, for the link . . . even if this means that I’m now casting my lot with the anti-Americans and am thus a fellow-travelor of anti-American wine terroirists!

   By the way, did you happen to see my entry on “José Ortega y Gasset: “Europa es el único continente que tiene un contenido.”

   That could also be construed as anti-American!

   At least I’m doing well in Korea as “His Joseon Highness” . . . but that might just be the third anti-American strike against me.

   I guess I’m out.

   Jeffery Hodges

   * * *