Trebots @ Tuesday March 29th 2005 20:10

Not so much flogging as snogging a dead horse, here is an excerpt from Rafael Miralles Bravo's Memorias de un comandante rojo (1975), quoted by Fernando Díaz-Plaja in Anecdotario De La Guerra Civil Española (previous post), dealing with the brief civil war within a civil war in May 1937:

The 4th passed without incidents other than those already noted. Some Barcelona neighbourhoods found themselves in the hands of the FAI [fairly naive pro-FAI article]. This was the case in Sans, where the Bakuninists had hastened to proclaim a state of communist libertarianism, and at the entry to which, opposite the Plaza de España itself, fluttered a gigantic poster with the following inscription: "Independent Republic of Murcia. Here ends Cataluña. Forbidden to speak Catalan."

Díaz-Plaja adds:

They'd gone too far if you consider that, following the entry of the Nationalist troops into Barcelona, Franco's feared anti-Catalanists had at least guaranteed that "no-one will impede the private and family use of Catalan."

The FAI never got round to declaring Murcian the official language. It just wasn't their style.

[FYI, a quick n stupid Weinreich-based ghit-count suggests that, quantitatively speaking, Catalan is much more of a language than Murcian, but that both pale into nothing compared with Spanish:

catalan(a) murcian@ español(a)
marina 227 1 12,300
ejército 88 1 42,400

]

Categories: Liberals & locals

RSS: post comments, blog comments, blog posts

You can leave a response or trackback from your site.

  1. Carlos Ferrero
    May 20th 2005 11:25

    Timothy Garton-Ash cites in his book "Historia del presente" ("History of the Present". 2000: Barcelona. Tusquets. Translated by María Rodríguez Tapia. p.243) the famous aphorism from Weinreich "A language is a dialect with an army" ---which, according to the Wikipedia, is actually from Hubert Lyautey. In a footnote, Garton-Ash ironically comments: "Perhaps it could be said that a State is a language with an army".

  2. Trevor
    May 20th 2005 11:47

    I'm looking for a Murcian intercambio - why take chances?

  3. kalebeul » The minister’s knickers
    June 30th 2005 18:26

    [...] -speaking underclass against their Catalan-speaking landlords and formed the background to this kind of stuff during the mass killings here in the summer of 1936. Staged po [...]

  4. kalebeul » The madness of Níjar
    July 12th 2005 14:09

    [...] ys destroy themselves from inside out, whether we’re talking about Münster in 1534, Barcelona in 1936, or (allegedly) gay tea dances in 1990s London. This betrayal i [...]

  5. J.D.
    February 29th 2008 14:29

    Catalan was also banned by Louis XIV in 1700 following occupation of Cataluña by the French, who have always taken a sterner view in such matters than the Spanish.

 

Nowish

  • Barroso says we're making progress, but are his savings still in Portugal?
  • Did Anish Kapoor really not realise that everyone was going to call Mittal's folly the Arsehole Orbit?
  • So what if Spain 10 year yields are 6%? Portugal hasn't been under 10 for a year

Picture-posts

Back to top