anythingarian bubbles and troubles from the land of the fretting nun
/ kalebeul / 2005 / 01 / 02 / el barca francos favourite team /
El Barça, Franco’s favourite team?
Skip to: comments (20); categories; related posts; previous/next postThe claim that Franco sought to benefit Real Madrid at the expense of FC Barcelona is, along with with half-truths like the banning of the language and blatant lies like the banning of the sardana, a key element in Catalanista victimist mythology, and has been readily embraced by innocents from abroad. Here’s a Chris Nawrat piece for the British Channel 4, based on Jimmy Burns’ Barça: A People’s Passion:
[...]
Real Madrid - Franco’s team - was to be deified. Officially. State-controlled Spanish television continually showed highlights of Real’s matches and very little of Barça’s, thus generating the notion among the populace that Real were Spain’s team. A Franco stooge Barça president managed to ‘lose’ Alfredo Di Stefano to their arch rivals when they’d already signed him. Di Stefano went on to lead Real to five successive European Cup victories.
The Spanish referees were also got at in a regime of terror. Not only did they favour Real in any encounter with Barça, the 1940s, 50s, 60s and 70s were also littered with bizarre - and obviously biased - refereeing decisions in other matches involving Barça which cost them championships and Cups. The decisions were so appalling that eventually even a puppet Barça president had the temerity to complain to the Spanish College of Referees. He was ignored.
Etcetera. Here, from the notably even-handed Anti-Barcelona.com, is part of the case for the defence:
Protectionism. The Barcelona public …, incited by an aggressive press campaign which counted on the collaboration of Juan Antonio Samaranch, resulted in the first displays of sporting terrorism, intimidating Real in their 1943 Cup semi-final away match. Madrid won the subsequent game 11-1.
[...]
The Regime’s team. From the end of the Civil War until the arrival at Real Madrid of Alfredo Di Stéfano, Barcelona was the most successful team… At the beginning of the 60s, Barcelona had a large deficit which it decided to pay off with the sale to developers of the old Les Corts ground. Since it was green belt, the council rejected the scheme but, after losing various appeals, the Council of Ministers, presided over by Franco, gave the project the go-ahead… In 1974 the dictator received the club’s 75th Anniversary Gold Medal.
Mini-charts of the absolute and relative (Real position - Barça position) league positions of Real Madrid and FC Barcelona during the Second Republic and the Franco dictatorship tend to support this interpretation. There’s a fairly clear correlation between periods of repression (40s, early 50s, early 70s) and Barcelona successes, while Real did better during periods of comparative openness (early 30s, late 50s, 60s).
I doubt, however, that evidence will ever emerge of any clear causal connection explaining football results in terms of government policy or Franco’s personal preferences. The closest we will probably get is in the Atlético’s string of post-war successes, when, as Atlético Aviación, it was sponsored by the armed forces. Allegedly. The same Santiago Bernabéu hagiography contains an anecdote from the period. Bernabéu escaped murder by the left and fought with the rebels during the war, but this was not, apparently, always enough:
There, some more lies to debunk.
Trevor @ 2 January 2005 4:04 PM
Hate this blog? Reduce posts via our books4beer scheme
All commission on second-hand sales via this site of Barça: a people’s passion: or other books by Jimmy Burns will be spent in a wifi-free pub. More books here.
Categories
Les bourgeois, Liberals & locals, Of ball games, Unamuno, Miguel deRelated posts
- Another lazy journalist
- Catalan corruption
- Quantitative analysis by language of Barcelona publications in British Library Integrated Catalogue
- Felix Schlayer and the Nazis
- follies
Previous/next post
«« Reducing corruption in Morocco ««»» Small town estate agent »»
Comments
Trackback link.
Tell me if the spam dragon gives you a hard time. Log in if you want to be really foul.
- FollowTheBaldie.com goes global
- What does Zapatero do when his internet connection is down?
- Hypo Real State
- Don’t crap here, we’re full already
- Italian elite regiment forced to climb Alps carrying bicycles and machine guns
- Coffin Joe vs Vicky Christina Barcelona
- Multi-lingual, multi-cultural slow-change act
- Cameo appearance by George Borrow in Valle-Inclán novel
- Coffin Joe and the King of Persia
- TIME on Sanjurjo’s 1932 coup attempt
- Iron Maiden in the frontline of the flag war on Basque terrorism
- When Zapatero only got 763 ghits
- Chess doping scandal
- L/n swaps
- The decline of the Spanish race
kalebeul
open source and uses Linux,
Apache, MySQL,
WordPress, PHP · Sing along with Moo Way (MP3) · 54 in 1.142
11:35 AM on 25 March 2005
It makes perfect sense that Franco would favour Barça. Cataluña was a major industrial region and there’s no point in pissing people off unnecessarily. Croat Tito was so successful in Serb-dominated Yugoslavia for the same reason - if you’re good to troublesome minorities they’ll shut up.
3:47 PM on 25 March 2005
You are a dumbass. Franco and his fascist machine killed our president and forced half our team into exile. Franco did as much as he could to ruin our team, and its a testament to our drive and passion that we survived him. You are truly ignorant.
9:10 PM on 25 March 2005
Have you got any evidence that he tried? Can you explain why an all-powerful dictator should have failed? Why do the stats show Barça doing better during the worst repression?
1:50 AM on 30 March 2005
I think you both, Geoff and Trevor, should read something, I don’t know exactly what but it should be quickly, before your brain helplessly dries out. First and last of all, if you need an evidence just look back on History: the president of the FC Barcelona WAS KILLED BY FASCISTS at the very begining of the war. That’s enough, isn’t it?
The reason why who you call the ‘all-powerfull dictator’ did fail is basically because he was incredibly moron!
Besides, we haven’t been struggling againts fascists to end up trying to convince of the true facts to a bunch of just landed Pommies
10:06 AM on 30 March 2005
FC Barcelona says that Suñol was killed because of his political activities–he was a prominent separatist. (I am told that the trainer of Espanyol was taken away from the ground and shot by anarchists at the beginning of the war, but again it had little or nothing to do with football: his sister was a nun.) If you’ve got any evidence to the contrary (or to support the ridiculous Franco-hated-Barça claim), I’m sure you’ll produce it.
10:30 AM on 4 June 2005
i love barça that s all
3:35 PM on 29 March 2006
… Sunyol was killed…fine I’ll admit that
..what about our president president Rafael Sánchez Guerra, a prominent Republican, was imprisoned and tortured his VP was arrested & Murderd, the Club treasurer was Prisoned & Murdered
why do people forget what happened to Real Madrid as well
so now tell me who suffered more???
Barca keep their lies around the glob no one stands for Real Madrid..
the team was forced to exile because
1- there was a Civil war so they ran for safety reasons nothing more
2- the liga was supended for 4 bloody years
so it made no affect what so ever on Barca.
6:54 PM on 29 March 2006
It seems fairly obvious that Real suffered at least as much as Barça, but is there another team out there that thinks it did even worse?
7:15 PM on 28 September 2006
Wikipedia says about Di Stefano:
On 1953, Di Stéfano signed a deal with FC Barcelona and the FIFA authorized the transfer from River Plate, the club that still had his rights, but the Spanish Federation did not. On May 13, 1953, he arrived to Spain to sign his contract with Barcelona but, during the troubles with the Federation, Real Madrid’s president Santiago Bernabéu convinced him to sign for them. Additionally, Real Madrid had negotiated with Millonarios.
On September 15, the Spanish Federation made public its decision to allow Di Stéfano four seasons in Spain, two in each team, to be played alternately. Barcelona protested and finally renounced on October 23. The reasons of this decision are different on each side. While the Real Madrid has always maintained it was a voluntary decision of Barcelona, their rivals denounced pressure from the Spanish dictatorial government. This incident exacerbated the traditional enmity between the two clubs. Di Stéfano finally debuted with Madrid on September 23.
7:17 PM on 28 September 2006
No one knows who killed Sunyol. He went with some other guys to the Madrid front to do some war tourism while carrying a large sum of money. They were all found dead and the money was gone, so it could have equally been Republican gangsters in the know.
8:34 PM on 24 January 2007
Dear friends,
Dictator Franco in my modest opinion was fun of Real Madrid. I am sorry that I cannot read anything about Barcelaona s best team, of 1960s. They lost final match vs Benfica, but no one can forget fantastic players such as Cocsis, Csibor, Evaristo, Cubala, although Laci did not play in Zurich.
12:51 AM on 21 October 2007
“…half-truths like the banning of the language …”
I married a Catalan woman. We had to notorize her birth certificate to marry. Her birth certificate was in Castellano and later, Catalan. Why? Because of the evil dictatorship of Franco. Trevor, thanks for the provocation, but you make things sound like they didn’t happen. You are very wrong, and need to talk to more Catalan and merengue fans to who lived through the cruel dictator’s reign.
1:55 PM on 11 December 2007
WHAT A COMPLETE MORAN YOU MUST BE. AN INCREDIBLY UNEDUCATED ACCOUNT OF A VERY TRAUMATIC TIME.
2:07 PM on 11 December 2007
Indeed.
I believe he’s one of the County Antrim Morans.
1:30 AM on 23 December 2007
[...] va leurs creuser onze tombes. J’ai la certitude que le Fc Barcelona gagnera son match contre les lèches bottes du Général Franco. Dans l’engagement et le combat on est des vrais guerriers honnêtes et c’est pour cette raison [...]
2:11 PM on 5 March 2008
[...] va leurs creuser onze tombes. J’ai la certitude que le Fc Barcelona gagnera son match contre les lèches bottes du Général Franco. Dans l’engagement et le combat on est des vrais guerriers honnêtes et c’est pour cette raison [...]
1:32 AM on 19 May 2008
Fuck me.
It’s Nostradamus.
6:57 PM on 27 May 2008
“On 1953, Di Stéfano signed a deal with FC Barcelona and the FIFA authorized the transfer from River Plate, the club that still had his rights, but the Spanish Federation did not. On May 13, 1953, he arrived to Spain to sign his contract with Barcelona but, during the troubles with the Federation, Real Madrid’s president Santiago Bernabéu convinced him to sign for them. Additionally, Real Madrid had negotiated with Millonarios.”
So when the FC Barcelona webpage itself lies about what it really happened what can we expect from them?
River Plate DID NOT hold Di Stefano’s rights in 1953. It was Millonarios de Bogotá who held them, at least until the beggining of 1955. As Barcelona had agreed a deal with River Plate and Real Madrid had done the same with Millonarios we could be said that both clubs shared Di Stefano’s rights. Both Barcelona and Real Madrid accepted the same man who had helped Barcelona in their purchase of Kubala some years before than that, as an intermediary to solutionate the problem. So as a salomonic choice the player would play two seasons in Real Madrid and the other two at Barcelona. Marti Carreto had to resign because of the numeorus critics from both staff of directives and fans and Barcelona refused to share the player, so Real Madrid had to pay Millonarios, River Plate and Barcelona to finally get the player.
11:41 AM on 12 July 2008
Franco was so opposed to Catalan teams that Catalonia was allowed to play Spain twice during the dictatorship. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catalonia_national_football_team#The_Franco_Era There has been no match since the restoration of democracy.
2:17 PM on 12 September 2008
The Francoist regime hated FC Barcelona that much, that rezoned Barça’s ground in Les Corts THREE TIMES during the 50s and 60s, which clearly saved the Catalan club from going bankrupted in that age.
On the contrary, Bernabeu’s plan to rezone Real Madrid’s stadium and build new bigger one on a different area was rejected by Francoist authorities just a few years later.
Common sense and cule propaganda just don’t fit well together, do they? Why are there so many lies and half-truths on internet about this matter? It’s not a difficult question to answer I can assure so…