/ kalebeul / 2004 / 09 / 06 / submarooned /

Submarooned

Skip to: comments (9); categories; related posts; previous/next post

We just had a typically ill-informed discussion here about how Narcís Monturiol’s second submarine, Ictíneo II, worked. Robert Hughes’ Barcelona says that

for surface running, Monturiol decided to save the muscles of his crew and install a six-horsepower steam engine. But you could not run a steam engine underwater: it would use up all the oxygen and turn the hull into an oven.

If you use a conventional coal- or wood-powered boiler the first objection makes sense, but I don’t see why regulating the temperature (or humidity) of the vessel should be a problem. Anyway, Hughes continues:

Monturiol had to find another way to raise heat, and thus steam. After prolonged experiment he came up with a form of chemical reaction between potassium chlorate, zinc and manganese dioxide. It produced more than enough heat to boil water and (as a bonus) oxygen as well, which was purified and piped back into the air in the hull. This chemical furnace could not raise enough power to drive the main engine, so Monturiol linked it to a smaller, two-horsepower steam motor for underwater running.

I’m intrigued to know what this reaction was. If you want oxygen, you heat potassium chlorate (2 KClO₃ → 2 KCl + 3 O₂), and mix manganese dioxide into the KClO₃ to reduce the temperature at which reaction takes place. So was Monturiol handing over some of the oxygen to his fellow-socialists and burning off the rest with powdered zinc to power his auxiliary motor, was it all mixed up like a big (and for me confusing) firework, or was something else happening? And did the fact that he didn’t attract military support for his project have something to do with the fact that potassium chlorate is prone to explode?

I’ve heard that the replica in Barcelona harbour is strictly nonfunctional (rather like the clunky costume drama for which it was built, Francesc Bellmunt’s 1992 Monturiol, el senyor del mar) and I suspect that Matthew Stewart’s new book, Monturiol’s Dream, is non-technical, so I’m afraid that I will need to lay hands on a copy of Monturiol’s Ensayo sobre el arte de navegar por debajo del agua. Oh dear.

(Robert Hughes also speculates that the magnificent Monturiol may have provided Victor Hugo with inspiration for Captain Nemo and his Nautilus, but I wonder. One can brush over the differences between the surface-down philanthropy of Monturiol and the depths-up vengefulness of Nemo–a metaphorical son-of-Moby, pursuing a generalised Ahab–but the fact that Hugo mentions but doesn’t adopt anaerobism suggests to me that he had no serious knowledge of Monturiol. Otherwise Barcelona would surely have figured in the list of suppliers for the Nautilus:

Its keel was forged in Creusot, its propeller shaft at Pen & C°, of London, the hull plates at Leard, of Liverpool, its propeller at Scott, of Glasgow. Its tanks were manufactured by Cail & C°, of Paris, its engine by Krupp, in Prussia, its spur in the workshops of Motala, in Sweden, its precision instruments at Hart brothers, of New York, etc, and each one of these suppliers received my plans under different names.)

Trevor @ 6 September 2004 4:49 PM

Hate this blog? Reduce posts via our books4beer scheme

All commission on second-hand sales via this site of Barcelona or other books by Robert Hughes will be spent in a wifi-free pub. More books here.

Previous/next post

«« Slavery and the Nigerian horse scam ««
»» Sand!! »»

Comments

RK
5:46 PM on 6 September 2004
He does use potassium chlorate to produce oxygen on the moon, but isn’t the temperature quoted, 400deg, its decomposition temperature without a catalyst?

Hope you found that confusing.
Carles
11:29 PM on 8 September 2004
Jules Verne = Victor Hugo?!
Trevor
11:34 PM on 8 September 2004
What, you mean you didn’t know?! Time for a drink.
Geoff
12:55 AM on 9 September 2004
I happen to know that Trevor doesn’t know how a frigging bicycle works.
Trevor
6:24 AM on 9 September 2004
Two words, pronounced as if by a Frenchman: Sturmey-Archer. Ever had your head inside one of those?
John Monturiol
1:53 AM on 12 January 2005
I believe it was Jules Vernes, not Victor Hugo. Have you read the Ensayo yet? just curious…
Trevor
11:35 AM on 12 January 2005
Yep, just get confused in my head at times.
Eric
6:23 PM on 16 January 2008
RE: “Twenty Thousand Leagues Under The Sea”

Trevor,

You will enjoy reading this novel very much. I envy you the first time experience but you needn’t search for it using Victor Hugo as the author…

It was written by Jules Verne whose inspiration came, in no small part, from the experiences of Narcis Monturiol.

Kindly,
Eric
Trevor ap Simon
3:27 PM on 17 January 2008
Someone already nailed me on that one, I’m afraid (see comments 2 and 6). I have stopped drinking anis and no longer suffer embarrassments of this or any other nature.