Trebots @ Monday July 12th 2004 01:23: caveat lector!

Philip Resnik is not convinced that there was any "tradition of valuing other cultures as successive waves of immigrants settled in the United States":

Yup, a great tradition, exemplified so nicely by our nation's coining the term "liberty sandwich" to replace "hamburger" during World War I ... and exemplified more recently by all those good multicultural GOP lawmakers who suggested that we replace "French fries" with "freedom fries" on our beloved fast food menus.

I beg to differ: in the first case, a German word is replaced by a Franco-Brit compound, and (English) freedom and (Romance) fries also arrived on boats. Prone to exaggeration, I would also ask whether we are really sure we know what Philemon Holland was on about when he wrote in his Suetonius of those who "died for the Libertie and Free-dome of their Cittie."

PS: A Leeuwarder gentleman of my acquaintance persists in pronouncing fries to rhyme with niece. Were this to be widely adopted in Republican circles then the political repercussions in Friesland, Holland could be quite considerable.

RSS: post comments / blog comments / blog posts / email / Twitter

Both comments and pings are currently closed.

  1. John Smith
    July 12th 2004 02:10

    I'm afraid Libertie sandwiches and Free-dome fries arrived in Rome with Macdonalds.

  2. Trevor
    July 12th 2004 02:23

    I'll bet the Romans fried parsnips, and this page describes how to make an authentic Roman burger. If you look at it that way, what have the Americans ever done for us?

  3. John Smith
    July 12th 2004 02:32

    Ketchup, that's what, although the OED will probably betray me.

  4. Trevor
    July 12th 2004 02:50

    Do not fear: people tend to betray their sauces rather than vice versa.

  5. Trevor
    July 12th 2004 02:51

    It might ketchup with you, tho.


Back to top